If you have been arrested before, one of the first questions after a new arrest is usually some version of this: will my past come back to hurt me? In Texas, the honest answer is that it can, but how much depends on what is actually on your record and where your new case stands. Here is how prior charges and convictions tend to come into play, and what you can do about it.
Arrests, charges, and convictions are not the same
Not everything on a background check carries the same weight. An arrest means you were taken into custody. A charge means prosecutors formally accused you of an offense. A conviction means you were found guilty or pleaded guilty and the court entered a judgment.
Deferred adjudication sits in its own category. If you completed deferred adjudication successfully, Texas generally does not treat it as a conviction, but the record of the arrest and the case can remain, and it can still come up in certain situations. Knowing exactly which category each past case falls into is one of the first things your attorney will want to sort out.
Bail
Criminal history comes into play early. When a magistrate sets bail, the person's record is one of the factors considered. Someone with prior convictions, or a history of missed court dates, may face a higher bond or stricter conditions of release than someone with a clean record.
The charge itself
For some offenses, a prior conviction changes what the State can charge. A third DWI, for example, is a felony in Texas even when the first two were misdemeanors. Certain theft and family violence offenses can also be raised to a higher level because of past convictions. Prior felony convictions can increase the punishment range on a new felony as well. These enhancements can turn a manageable case into a much more serious one, which is why your full history matters from day one.
Plea negotiations
Prosecutors look at your record when deciding what to offer. A first-time offender may be considered for options like a pretrial diversion program or deferred adjudication. Someone with prior cases may find those options limited or off the table. That does not mean a good outcome is out of reach, but it does change the starting point for negotiations.
At trial
As a general rule, the State cannot use your past to argue that you probably committed this offense because you did something similar before. There are exceptions, and if you choose to testify, certain prior convictions may be raised to challenge your credibility. Whether and how your record could come up at trial is an important part of deciding whether to testify at all.
Sentencing
If a case reaches the punishment stage, criminal history often carries real weight. A judge or jury deciding a sentence can generally consider your prior record, along with everything else presented about you.
If you are already on probation or deferred adjudication
A new arrest while you are on community supervision or deferred adjudication can create a second problem on top of the new charge. The State may file a motion to revoke your probation or to proceed to an adjudication of guilt on the earlier case. That means you could be defending two cases at once, and the outcome of one can affect the other. If this is your situation, it is especially important to talk with an attorney quickly.
Can old records be cleared?
Sometimes. Texas offers two main tools for older records.
An expunction removes records of an arrest and charge entirely. It is generally available for cases that did not end in a conviction, such as some dismissals and acquittals, and it comes with its own eligibility rules.
An order of nondisclosure seals certain records from the public, including many successfully completed deferred adjudications. Sealed records are hidden from most employers and landlords, but law enforcement and prosecutors can generally still see them. That is an important point if you are facing a new charge: a sealed record is not the same as no record.
Eligibility for either option depends on the offense, how the case ended, and how much time has passed. If you have older cases that might qualify, it may be worth looking into once your current case is resolved.
What to do now
Be completely honest with your attorney about your history, even cases you think are old, minor, or sealed. Your lawyer cannot plan around something they do not know about, and the State will likely find it anyway. If you have paperwork from past cases, gather it. And avoid discussing the facts of your new case with anyone other than your attorney.
The bottom line
A past record does not decide your new case, but it can shape bail, the charge, plea offers, and sentencing. The sooner an experienced criminal defense attorney sees the full picture, the more options there are to protect you.
If you are facing a new charge and worried about your record, schedule a confidential consultation with Schneider Law Firm.
Fort Worth | Alliance/Keller | Mansfield/Arlington
This article is general information about criminal law in Texas and is not legal advice. Every case is different, and how your history affects a new case depends on the specific facts and the county where your case is handled.